DETAILED ANALYSIS
Key Differences Between Transfer and Transmission of Shares
While the comparison table above provides a quick snapshot, let us explore the difference between transfer and transmission of shares in greater depth across the most important dimensions.
Voluntary vs Involuntary Nature
The most fundamental difference lies in the nature of the act. Transfer is always a voluntary, deliberate act — the shareholder consciously decides to part with their shares. They negotiate the terms, sign the transfer deed, and hand over the share certificates willingly. Transmission, on the other hand, is entirely involuntary. It happens due to circumstances beyond anyone's control — death, insolvency, or incapacity. No negotiation takes place, and no transfer deed is executed.
Documents and Formalities
For transfer, the primary document is the Share Transfer Deed (Form SH-4), which must be properly stamped and signed by both parties. For transmission, the documents are evidence-based — the claimant must prove their right to the shares through a death certificate, succession certificate, probate of will, legal heir certificate, or an insolvency order. The documentation for transmission is often more extensive because the claimant must establish their legal entitlement.
Stamp Duty Implications
This is a practical difference that affects cost. Share transfer attracts stamp duty at 0.25% of the consideration or market value. No stamp duty is payable on transmission because there is no sale or exchange — the shares pass by operation of law. This distinction can be financially significant when dealing with large share holdings.
Company's Right to Refuse
A company (particularly a private company) has the right to refuse registration of a transfer under Section 58, subject to the restrictions in its Articles of Association. However, a company cannot refuse transmission of shares if the claimant has submitted all the required legal documents. Transmission is a right that flows from the law itself, not from the company's discretion.
Practical Tip: If you are dealing with old physical share certificates — whether for transfer or transmission — consider getting them dematerialised first. SEBI has mandated that all transfer requests for listed company shares must be processed only in demat form. Transmission, however, can still be done in physical form.